Article

Advantages of Hybrid Beamforming Versus Digital Beamforming
January 2025 Pantelis Trakas, Principal Product Manager, Wireless Network Systems
image of a village

In the rapidly evolving world of wireless communications, beamforming technologies are central to improving signal quality, optimizing bandwidth, and enhancing overall network performance. Beamforming is particularly vital in the context of advanced wireless technologies like mmW FWA and Wi-Fi 6, which rely on efficient and high-capacity transmission of data across multiple users. Among the various beamforming techniques, digital beamforming and hybrid beamforming are two key approaches, each offering distinct advantages and trade-offs.

Digital beamforming involves fully digital signal processing at each antenna element. By independently controlling the phase and amplitude of signals for each antenna element, it enables precise control over beam direction. This makes digital beamforming highly effective in dense environments with high user density and multi-path propagation. However, its implementation requires significant computational resources, leading to higher costs and power consumption.

Hybrid beamforming, on the other hand, combines digital and analog signal processing techniques. This approach splits the signal processing into two stages: digital beamforming at the baseband and analog beamforming in the radio frequency (RF) domain. By leveraging analog components to manage groups of antennas, hybrid beamforming reduces the hardware complexity and power consumption associated with fully digital systems. This scalability and efficiency make hybrid beamforming particularly suitable for large-scale systems like massive MIMO arrays in 5G and purpose built mmW FWA networks.

Beamforming: Enhancing Connection Reliability and Network Efficiency

Beamforming is a cornerstone of advanced wireless communication, playing a critical role in improving signal quality and optimizing network performance. By directing signals in specific paths rather than broadcasting them uniformly, beamforming achieves higher gain, resulting in longer and more reliable connections even in challenging environments. The technology also minimizes interference by focusing energy in targeted directions, which is particularly beneficial in dense deployment scenarios. Additionally, beamforming serves as a foundation for Multi-User (MU) connectivity through spatial separation, enabling simultaneous communication with multiple devices. This capability enhances network capacity and efficiency, making beamforming indispensable for modern wireless systems, including those leveraging mmW spectrum and massive MIMO arrays.

Advantages of Hybrid Beamforming Over Digital Beamforming
  • Lower Power Consumption

    Hybrid beamforming reduces the reliance on power-intensive digital components, significantly decreasing energy consumption. This is particularly important in mobile networks, where base stations and user equipment must operate under strict power constraints. By improving energy efficiency, hybrid beamforming also reduces operational costs and enhances the sustainability of wireless networks.

  • Cost Efficiency

    The fully digital approach of digital beamforming necessitates a large number of ADCs, DACs, and DSPs, which increases both hardware and computational expenses. In contrast, hybrid beamforming minimizes the need for such components, making it a cost-effective solution for large antenna arrays.

  • Scalability

    Massive MIMO systems, a cornerstone of advanced ultra broadband wireless access technologies, require handling a vast number of antennas to serve multiple users simultaneously. Digital beamforming’s high computational demand limits its scalability. Hybrid beamforming, with its ability to group antennas and reduce digital processing, provides a scalable alternative for large systems.

  • Simplified Hardware Design

    Hybrid beamforming reduces the need for individual ADCs and DACs for each antenna element. This simplification of hardware design not only lowers costs but also facilitates the deployment of large antenna arrays in practical systems.

  • Improved Spectral Efficiency and Performance

    While digital beamforming excels in precision, hybrid beamforming achieves high spectral efficiency by combining digital and analog techniques. This balance enhances network capacity and reduces interference, making it ideal for high-throughput scenarios like mmW ultra broadband FWA networks.

  • Reduced Latency

    By leveraging analog components for faster signal processing at the RF stage, hybrid beamforming can reduce latency compared to fully digital systems. This advantage is crucial for applications requiring real-time communication, such as autonomous vehicles and virtual reality.

  • Use Cases and Applications

    Hybrid beamforming is well-suited for applications requiring high throughput and cost efficiency, such as mmWave Fixed Wireless Access (FWA) networks, massive MIMO deployments, and satellite communications. Its scalability and energy efficiency make it a preferred choice for large-scale wireless systems. Conversely, digital beamforming is better suited for smaller systems or environments requiring maximum flexibility and control over individual antenna beams.

image of a village
The WiBAS G5 smart-BS Solution

A prime example of hybrid beamforming technology is Intracom Telecom's WiBAS™ G5 smart-BS. This Point-to-Multipoint hub is part of the company’s ultra-broadband portfolio, designed to deliver interference-free connectivity in the 24.25-29.50 GHz mmWave band. By leveraging Multi-User MIMO and an Advanced Antenna System (AAS) for precise beamforming, the WiBAS™ G5 smart-BS achieves sector capacities of over 5 Gbps using up to 200 MHz channels. Paired with the WiBAS™ G5 GigaConnect+ terminal, it provides end-user speeds of up to 2 Gbps over distances of up to 8 km.

This cutting-edge solution supports up to 120 terminals per hub, making it ideal for dense FWA deployments in suburban and rural areas. Its rapid deployment capabilities and compatibility with 3GPP-based 5G systems ensure seamless integration into existing networks. Additionally, the WiBAS™ G5 smart-BS incorporates advanced features like hitless adaptive modulation up to 1024-QAM, low latency, and robust VLAN translation, catering to both direct and wholesale service models.

Conclusion

Hybrid beamforming represents a transformative approach to wireless communication, offering a balanced mix of performance, scalability, and cost-efficiency. By combining the strengths of digital and analog signal processing, hybrid beamforming addresses the challenges of modern wireless networks, particularly in the context of ultra broadband mmW Fixed Wireless Access networks and beyond.

As wireless technologies continue to evolve, solutions like the WiBAS™ G5 smart-BS underscore the practical advantages of hybrid beamforming. With its high capacity, energy efficiency, and seamless integration capabilities, the WiBAS™ G5 smart-BS exemplifies the potential of hybrid beamforming to drive the future of wireless communication.